On a summer day in the middle of the Civil War, immigrants furious about conscription notices delivered to their homes instigated the Boston draft riot.
The Boston draft riot was overshadowed by the much worse anti-draft violence in New York City, but an unknown number of rioters were killed and injured.
The rioters were mostly Irish, mostly working class. They included women and children who feared poverty and starvation if the men who supported them went off to fight the Civil War.
For $300, draftees could pay for substitutes, but that sum was out of the reach of Boston’s working-class immigrants. They viewed the conflict as a rich man’s war but a poor man’s fight.
Boston Draft Riot Begins
July 14 was a dog day, foggy and hot, remembered Maj. Stephen Cabot, called up to quell the violence.
Around lunchtime, David Howe and Wesley Hill, federal draft agents, were trudging through the tenements of Boston’s North End, then a working-class Irish neighborhood.
They were delivering the first federal draft notices in U.S. history.
When they reached Prince Street, irate Irish women began screaming at the draft agents. Men coming home for lunch from the gas works nearby heard her and began crowding around them.
Hill fled, but Howe was trapped and beaten. A police officer managed to rescue him, swinging his club and escorting him into a store for safety. Howe was beaten again when he tried to leave the store.
By late afternoon the angry crowd had grown. Boston police barricaded themselves in the station house for safety.
Gov. John Andrew was at the Harvard commencement. He called in troops from the forts in the harbor and local camps. Mayor Frederic Lincoln used the police telegraph to summon the militia. He ordered the troops to protect the armories.
One company went to protect the Marshall Street Armory, two went to Cooper Street under the command of Stephen Cabot.
Cabot took up position in the armory, aiming two cannon at the door as the mob converged outside.
Call in the Troops
He got word the crowd was beating a militiaman, so he sent soldiers with bayonets to save him. By then the rioters were tearing bricks from the sidewalk and threw them at the building.
Many of the rioters were women. Some held up their babies and dared the soldiers to fire at them.
The Boston Herald later described “one Amazonian woman, shouting and screaming, and urging the assailants on in their desperate work…with hair streaming, arms swinging, and her face the picture of phrenzy, she rushed again and again to the assault.
The mob began to attack the armory with sledgehammers and axes; the doors began to give way.
Inside the armory, Stephen Cabot gave the order to fire the cannon through the door. The soldiers fired and killed several in the crowd, including a 12-year-old boy.
The mob headed for the gun shops on Dock Square, but the police arrived ahead of them. They held off the rioters until more regular troops arrived and restored order.
The Harvard classes of 1852 and 1857 were holding reunions at the Parker House. They marched up School Street to the Statehouse to be mustered into all-night duty.
Tensions were easing, though small knots of people lingered. City and state officials asked for calm, while Catholic priests walked through the immigrant neighborhoods.
The next morning brought no more violence – unlike New York, where the riots raged for four days and killed 120 people.
With thanks to Historical Digression and Civil War Boston: Home Front and Battlefield by Thomas H. O’Connor. This story was updated in 2022.
[…] in Boston he met stenographer Rosa Gnecco, the daughter of a North End grocer. He didn’t tell her about his past, but his mother did in a letter from Italy. Rosa […]
[…] men and women like Guthrie who camped out in the church to escape 'Establishment pressures' and the draft. The neighbors hated the 'Beatnik commune.' They wrote letters to the editor complaining about it, […]
[…] The joke is referring to the Boston Draft Riot of July 14, 1863. The Enrollment Act, passed on March 3, allowed the federal government to draft citizens into the Union Army, and was the first federal draft in U.S. history. One could pay $300 to hire a substitute, so it was mainly working-class men who were being drafted. The riot started when a woman began yelling at two federal draft agents, Howe and Hill, near the Boston Gas Light Company, in the North End, which was a working-class Irish-American neighborhood at the time. Workers at the plant came out and surrounded the men. Hill got away, but Howe was beaten, until a police officer saved him. By the time the rest of the police arrived, it was an all-out riot. State troops were called in, led by Major Cabot, to secure the armory, so that rioters could not arm themselves with guns. When the rioters began breaking into the armory, Cabot ordered a canon to be fired at the door, which dispersed the crowd, but killed several men, women, and children. There was a much larger draft riot in New York the day before, which lasted four days and killed 120 people. All of this information was taken from Patrick Browne’s article, “Irish-Americans and the Boston Draft Riot, 150 Years Ago,” published on the Historical Digression website (linked here), and the New England Historical Society website (linked here). […]
Comments are closed.