Home Connecticut How New Haven Became Part of Connecticut: It Was the Regicides

How New Haven Became Part of Connecticut: It Was the Regicides

Killing a king has consequences


Had three regicides fled somewhere other than New Haven Plantation, Connecticut might look a lot different today.

regicides Charles_II_of_England_in_Coronation_robes

King Charles II

The three Puritan ‘king-killers’ who opposed King Charles I were among the 59 commissioners who sat in judgment of him and signed his death warrant. Charles was beheaded on Jan. 30, 1649, but the governments that succeeded him only lasted 11 years. His son Charles II became king on his 30th birthday, May 29, 1660, and sought revenge for his father’s killers.

About 20 regicides were executed. Some were drawn and quartered. Some fled to the Continent, but three fled to the Puritan colony of New Haven in 1661, where they expected to find refuge. They did.

After the Restoration, Edward Whalley and William Goffe fled together to North America, landing in Boston. John Dixwell went to New Haven. He made the better choice.

John Dixwell, Regicide

John Dixwell

William Goffe

John Dixwell was a colonel in the Parliamentary army and a member of four parliaments. When he arrived in New Haven Colony, it had been a staunch Puritan plantation since 1637. Over time it included Milford, Guilford, Stamford and Branford.

Dixwell immediately went undercover, assuming the name John Davids. Royalists in England believed he died, and never searched for him. He settled in a house near his friend the Rev. James Pierpont, an ancestor of Aaron Burr and J.P. Morgan. In 1673 he married widow Joanna Ling, and four years later he married Bathsheba How. They had a son and two daughters.

Regicides on the Lam

Edward Whalley fought under Oliver Cromwell, his cousin, during the English Civil War as a lieutenant general.

William Goffe married Whalley’s daughter Frances and became a major general in Cromwell’s army. Politically radical and deeply religious, he was known as ‘Praying William.’ After the Restoration, he and Whalley fled together to North America.

John Dixwell

John Dixwell

On July 27, 1660, they arrived in Boston, where they knew Increase Mather and Daniel Gookin. Gov. John Endecott received them warmly. They thought themselves safe and lived openly in Cambridge, believing rumors that all but seven of the regicides would receive pardons. Those turned out to be false.

As the new Parliament debated what to do with people who committed crimes (including king killing) during the Interregnum, Endecott began to wonder whether he should have greeted the regicides with open arms. On Feb. 22, 1661, he gathered a court of assistants to discuss whether to arrest the two men. Whalley and Goffe decided to head south. They left on February 26, and orders for their arrest arrived from Barbados on March 8.

The Regicides in New Haven

Whalley and Goffe arrived in New Haven two days after Boston magistrates received the royal order for their arrest. They hid out with a sympathetic minister, the Rev. John Davenport. When the news of their arrest orders arrived, they made a show of leaving for Milford, but returned secretly to New Haven that night. For two months they stayed with Davenport and other sympathizers as royal agents swept the countryside in search of them.

New Haven Gov. William Leete received the orders for their arrest in Guilford, but Leete sympathized with the regicides and delayed the king’s agents. That gave Whalley and Goffe enough time to escape and hide out in Judges Cave, where they lived most of the summer.

Judges Rock

Judges Cave

In August they moved to a house in Milford, where they lived for two years until their hideout was discovered.  They moved back to the cave until Indians found them. On Oct. 13, 1663, they set out for western Massachusetts, traveling only by night. They arrived in Hadley, Mass., where the Rev. John Russell sheltered them. Goffe managed to exchange letters with his wife, still in England. She sent him money.

In 1665, King Charles II punished New Haven for protecting the regicides. He merged the colony with Connecticut.

Angel of Hadley

During King Philip’s War, Indians attacked Hadley. According to legend, all seemed lost until a powerful-looking old man with a white beard and a sword appeared. He rallied the militia in a successful defense against the Indians and then disappeared. There is reason to believe the Angel of Hadley was William Goffe.

The Angel of Hadley

Edward Whalley is believed to have died in 1675 in Hadley. Goffe is believed to have died in Hartford some years later.

John Dixon died on March 18, 1689, in New Haven.

A seven-mile hiking trail in Connecticut’s West Rock Ridge State Park is called The Regicides Trail. Judges Cave, where they hid, is near the south end of the trail, which is within New Haven, Hamden, Woodbridge and Bethany. For more information, click here.

Lake Watrous, viewed from an overlook on the Regicides Trail.

New Haven named three intersecting streets after the regicides: Dixwell Avenue, Whalley Avenue and Goffe Street.

This story about the regicides was updated in 2023.

Images: View from Regicides Trail By Tebersold – Own work, CC BY-SA 3.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=17592991.


Dan E Horton March 23, 2015 - 8:22 pm

son of Col Thomas Horton found himself in Dorchester, Ma with 25 acres his father Col T Horton was one of those that signed the death edit of Charles I

Rachel Smith March 24, 2015 - 11:53 am

Yikes! This isn’t true at all. The merging of the Connecticut and New Haven colonies was codified in the famous Connecticut Charter of 1662, as the result of skillful and deliberate negotiation by CT’s governor, John Winthrop Jr. It wasn’t some kind of “royal punishment” issued in 1665 because of the New Haven regicides. Please be more diligent in your fact checking! http://connecticuthistory.org/the-charter-of-1662/

The Great Boston Revolt of 1689 - New England Historical Society April 18, 2015 - 7:36 am

[…] Charles ordered every male 16 years and older to swear allegiance to the king. Restrictions on trade and navigation were to be obeyed; and no one was to be prohibited from celebrating the ritual of the Church of England. Treason was again a crime. […]

The Maypole That Infuriated the Puritans - New England Historical Society May 1, 2015 - 8:48 am

[…] the Massachusetts Bay Colony, trying to revoke their charter. He succeeded, mostly because of King Charles’ animosity toward the Puritans. When the charter was revoked in 1634, Morton planned to return to Merrymount. But the Puritans […]

Boston Celebrates the Birth of a Prince in 1718 – and Lots of Other Royal Milestones - New England Historical Society May 4, 2015 - 3:31 pm

[…] Sewall noted in his diary ‘Colours are out, and Guns fire for K. Charles 2d Birth, Return.’ King Charles II had returned to England to claim the throne on his 30th birthday – in 1660, 60 years […]

Samuel Peters and the True History of Connecticut - New England Historical Society August 14, 2015 - 8:27 am

[…] in New Haven. The Colony itself had long been eliminated, in part because its leaders sheltered the Regicides who overthrew the king during the English Civil […]

Way More Than the Scarlet Letter: Puritan Punishments - New England Historical Society September 21, 2015 - 8:14 am

[…] Massachusetts, New Plymouth, Connecticut and New Haven Colony, the Puritans were more concerned with moral behavior and clean living than they were with property […]

Shattuck and The Devil Try To Stop Quaker Persecution in New England - New England Historical Society October 2, 2015 - 7:37 am

[…] Quakers went for help to King Charles II, a Catholic sympathizer and no friend of the Puritans, who had executed his father and sought refuge in New […]

Puritan Justice of the New Haven Colony: Sometimes Nasty and Brutish - New England Historical Society October 14, 2015 - 7:24 am

[…] New Haven Colony was established as a moral community – another theocratic ‘city on a hill’ — that adhered to […]

Noah Webster Cures the Blues With a Spelling Book - New England Historical Society October 16, 2015 - 8:49 am

[…] family was prominent, but poor. His father had to mortgage his farm to send him to Yale College in New Haven. The American Revolution disrupted his studies, causing food shortages and the threat of British […]

The Murder of Frank Sokolowsky – ‘For I Could Not Live Without Him…’ - New England Historical Society December 19, 2015 - 10:43 am

[…] his wife. But she was nowhere to be found. As police began looking, the found Alexandra had left New Haven, stopped briefly in Bridgeport, and from there had slipped into New York […]

Lady Deborah Moody - A Dangerous Woman Comes to New England - New England Historical Society January 5, 2016 - 10:40 am

[…] and land in Massachusetts. Peter had by now returned to England. He would eventually be executed as a regicide for his role in the trial and execution of Charles […]

The Hartford Controversy of 1650: ’Afraid to venture our souls’ - New England Historical Society April 18, 2017 - 8:56 am

[…] was his decision to shelter two judges who had tried and condemned King Charles I of England. The Regicides were driven from England when the monarchy was restored and hid with Russell until they […]

Benedict Arnold and the Rhode Island Quakers, Ranters and Heretics - New England Historical Society November 30, 2017 - 2:56 pm

[…] September of 1658, the United Colonies of New England – Plymouth, Massachusetts Bay, New Haven and Connecticut – issued a joint proclamation. They would neither welcome nor tolerate […]

Six French Place Names in Six New England States - New England Historical Society December 2, 2017 - 8:44 am

[…] Great Puritan Migration. He preached in Wethersfield, Conn., for a while. Then he joined a group of New Haven Colony settlers in Milford and was ordained pastor of the church in […]

How Scottish POWS Were Sold as Slave Labor in New England - New England Historical Society May 15, 2018 - 10:55 am

[…] and his Puritan followers executed King Charles I in January 1649. The Scottish people had largely sided with Cromwell, but Charles was born in […]

Unequal Justice for the Gay Puritans of New Haven Colony - New England Historical Society August 19, 2018 - 7:54 am

[…] established New Haven Colony as a moral community that followed Biblical law. Sometimes that meant harsh punishment and unequal […]

Thomas Kemble, The Kissing Puritan - New England Historical Society February 11, 2019 - 7:24 am

[…] In addition to the more mundane aspects of his trade, he also was consigned a group of 272 Scottish prisoners of war. They were  probably captured during the Battle of Worcester in September of 1651. During that fight, Oliver Cromwell's forces defeated the Scottish armies loyal to King Charles II. […]

Puritans Name, Shame and Take Over Anglican Maine - New England Historical Society March 15, 2019 - 6:52 am

[…] Black Point, Blue Point and Stratton’s Island became Scarborough, which in England had surrendered only a month before the execution of Charles I. […]

When Cleveland Belonged to Connecticut - New England Historical Society June 21, 2019 - 6:30 am

[…] Three king killers fled to America, where they found refuge in New Haven. Because of that, Winthrop knew Charles had attitude about Connecticut. […]

John Aylett, The Royalist Adventurer Who Owned a Boston Tavern - New England Historical Society July 3, 2019 - 7:25 am

[…] Three years later, the Parliamentarians executed Charles. […]

Divorce, Murder and Madness: The Puritan Tuttles of the New Haven Colony - New England Historical Society July 14, 2019 - 6:21 am

[…] And that’s where she died, in the custody of the magistrates of the New Haven Colony her father had hoped to build. […]

Reddy the Blacksmith and His New York Bowery Boys Invade Connecticut - New England Historical Society August 30, 2019 - 8:14 am

[…] after dark on the night of February 11, 1867, a train pulled into New Haven station carrying a load of these New York toughs. They went to one of the city’s darkest and […]

How the History of Petroleum Was Made in New England - New England Historical Society June 6, 2020 - 3:37 pm

[…] for James Townsend, who agreed to drum up interest among New Haven investors. He told them, though, that he couldn’t do it until they got a scientific report on the […]

The Puritans Burn the Book of Sports - New England Historical Society June 23, 2020 - 6:25 am

[…] of course, the Puritans took power in England and Charles lost his head. Many of the Puritans who left his repressive rule ended up returning to […]

Comments are closed.

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Join our mailing list to receive the latest artciles from the New England Historical Society

Thanks for Signing Up!

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Join Now and Get The Latest Articles. 

It's Free!

You have Successfully Subscribed!