The Phelps Sacrifice is the second part of a two-part series about one family’s tragic experience of the Civil War. Read Part I here.
Having already lost their father to the ravages of the Civil War, Leroy and Levant Phelps enlisted in the Union Army on Dec. 9, 1863, for three years. The Phelps sacrifice was far from over.
Garrison Duty in Washington
The Phelps brothers were assigned to the 1st Massachusetts Volunteer Heavy Artillery Regiment. This unit had a complex history. Originally organized on July 5, 1861, as the 14th Massachusetts Volunteer Infantry, it was reconstituted as an artillery regiment on Jan. 1, 1862. The regiment was sent to Washington, D.C., to help man the forts protecting the capital through 1862 and the first half of 1863. In June 1863, Company I was sent to the Shenandoah Valley and participated in the Second Battle of Winchester and the retreat to Harper’s Ferry. with Companie B, C, H, and I assigned for the rest of the year to the Department of West Virginia. The bulk of the regiment was assigned to the Department of West Virginia.
Defense of Washington, D.C. during the Civil War
By December, most of the regiment was back manning the forts around Washington, D.C., Here Leroy and Levant Phelps would have joined as replacements. With the one exception of Company I, the regiment had seen no major action, nor had it sustained any significant losses beyond illness and injury. At least their mother could take some solace in the fact that Leroy and Levant would not be directly involved in combat, the threat of Confederate forces attacking Washington being greatly diminished. Alas, it was a false hope.
Conversion to Infantry
By 1864, the need to keep large artillery regiments around Washington had diminished. But at the same time, the need for additional infantry had risen significantly. The army now began to look at the manpower of the heavy artillery units that had not been depleted by combat. And thus, on May 15, 1864, the regiment, while maintaining its artillery designation, was converted to infantry. It then joined the Army of the Potomac at Belle Plain, Va. Privates Leroy and Levant Phelps were now infantryman. While they may have been reluctant to tell their mother, they were probably initially glad to leave the dull, uneventful daily grind of manning the Washington fortifications. As the Regimental history noted:
At last, after long months of garrison duty, days of waiting and impatience to the majority who wanted action, a share in the fighting and glory of achievement; of disappointment to those who wanted to be in the field with other regiments that had won the laurels of war; of all who wanted to hasten the day of victory, and of peace that was consummately desired; at last came the orders which brought the regiment into the midst of the bloodiest conflicts of the war.
Baptism of Fire at Spotsylvania
In 1864, monumental battles took place in Virginia. Leroy and Levant would see their first real combat at the Battle of Spotsylvania Court House on May 19-21, 1864, just three days after the regiment’s conversion to infantry. It would have been a rude awakening for the regiment since they had only rudimentary training in ground combat. On the first day of the battle, at Harris Farm/Fredericksburg Road, the regiment found itself in the thick of the fighting.
Privates Leroy and Levant Phelps were in Company D. The regimental history has an entry written by a member of the company.
The right company, F, and our company, D, were detached as skirmishers and filed to the right of the line. The regiment passed on and the two companies under Maj. Holt started off to the right. Co. F left us to relieve the picket of the 4th N. Y. in our front, while our company marched on to the right. Here we halted near the picket reserve of the 4th N. Y. and waited for orders.
Soon after we halted, the pickets commenced exchanging shots and soon the firing became quite hot, but the reserve of the 4th N. Y. picket was ordered in to support this line.
The firing began to increase in intensity; the bullets hummed over our heads and we began to think there was a skirmish in earnest. Just then the first battalion under Rolfe came up in double quick, formed in line of battle to the right of us.
‘Fix bayonets, forward’
Maj. Rolfe said to his command: “Men, we want to see if there are Rebels in those woods; if there are we must drive them out. Battalion, fix bayonets, forward, guide centre, march.” And down they went. They reached the woods, joining the 4th N. Y. The fight began soon.
Co. D was ordered to the right or near the centre, where we could see the whole fight. Maj. Rolfe was riding up and down his line urging his men on. I thought he was rash, for he was in uniform and a conspicuous target. Our company was sent to cover behind a house close by. Some of our men were wounded, but our ambulance corps was not on hand. DeMeritt of our company, severely wounded in both legs, I placed in a 2d N. Y. ambulance. After a time the Rebels were too strong and our company had to fall back.
Our second battalion came up and we rallied in the woods and drove the Rebels from the house we had just left, but they came back and again we reformed in the woods. Here the battery on the hill in our rear opened on the Rebs and two of their shots struck among our men, killing one of Co. G and taking a leg off one in D. The 2d N. Y. came up and fired a volley into us instead of the enemy.
We gained the house again and, protected by that and a rail fence, held the position until reinforcements came, when we helped drive the Rebels down the hill.
The 2d N. Y. were entirely disorganized. They had the line in advance of ours in the evening and, while our troops were putting in their volleys the 2d N. Y. broke and fell back on us.

The 1st Massachusetts Heavy Artillery Regiment bury dead Confederates at the Alsop Farm May 19, 1864.
The Cost of Harris Farm
Company D lost four killed and 18 wounded.
As the 1st Massachusetts Heavy Artillery monument at the Harris Farm states:
In commemoration of the deeds of the First Regiment Heavy Artillery Massachusetts Volunteers (Armed as Infantry) three hundred and ninety eight of whose members fell within an hour around this spot during an action fought May 19 1864 between a division of the Union Army commanded by General Tyler and a corps of the Confederate forces under General Ewell.
Considering their lack of training as infantry and that they were seriously outnumbered, the regiment and the Phelps brothers acquitted themselves well. They were lucky to survive unscathed. The remaining men had to learn their trade on the fly since, only two days later on May 23rd, they were involved in the fighting at the North Anna River and at Totopotomoy. In both instances, they did not engage heavily with the enemy.
A Respite During the Battle of Cold Harbor
The regiment was then involved in the Battle of Cold Harbor (June 1-12, 1864). Though a bloodbath for the Union Army, fortunately for the regiment it did not suffer as heavily as others. The regimental history has an interesting entry regarding a quiet phase of the battle when even the Confederates appear exhausted.
June 7, Cutler writes: This is the first day for some time that we have not been under fire. We have had some good resting spells lately and feel greatly refreshed after the hard service we saw after starting from the forts.
The Rebel pickets opposite our lines are quite sociable and quiet; not a shot has been fired by either side. The firing last night was on the right of us. They are North Carolina troops. Our pickets trade coffee and sugar with them for tobacco. They have no coffee or sugar, but plenty of other food. One man gave himself over to our forces. He says he has plenty to eat, but his family is suffering. They all think the war will not last much longer, but say that Grant will have a hard time taking Richmond…
A Truce, and the Siege of Petersburg
On the seventh a truce was arranged from 6 to 8 p.m., to get off the wounded and bury the dead. Some of the wounded had lain exposed to sun and rain on the battle fields since the third, and their sufferings were terrible. The stench from dead bodies was unbearable. The terrible scene seemed to have an effect on both armies and, though the firing of musketry was heard later, many a shot went high in the air. Cutler says he did not hear a picket shot on the eighth. In the afternoon he enjoyed corn bread secured from the Rebs and he wanted more of it. In the evening the batteries exchanged shots…
Only four days after Cold Harbor, on June 16, 1864, the regiment joined the Siege of Petersburg. They would fight in the siege lines and in the various battles in the area until Petersburg fell on April 2, 1865. For the remainder of 1864, Pvts. Leroy and Levant Phelps participated in the First Assault on Petersburg. Then they fought on the Jerusalem Plank Road, Deep Bottom, Strawberry Plains, Peeble’s Farm, Boydton Plank Road/Hatcher’s Run and the Expedition to Weldon Railroad.
The Final Campaign
Through early March 1865, the 1st Massachusetts Heavy Artillery was involved in only one significant action at Dabney’s Mills/Hatcher’s Run (Feb. 3-7, 1865) other than service in the siege lines. Then on March 29, 1865, Grant and the Army of the Potomac began their final campaign, the Appomattox Campaign.
On March 31, 1865, the regiment and the Phelps brothers found themselves in a familiar area near Boydton Plank Road. It was a minor affair given their previous combat, but it would be a lasting memory for the Phelps’ family. The regimental history describes the action:
March 31, 1865. After being moved to the left in the morning, our brigade and the 5th Mich, were sent forward at 11 a. m. and three hours later advanced upon a Rebel fort under a terrible fire, that somehow proved very ineffective. We came to an impassable morass just in front of the fort and lay down there, maintaining a heavy fire, and exposed not only to the fire from the enemy’s infantry in the works but to canister from their battery. Staff officers in the rear of our lines sat on their horses, coolly surveying the enemy’s works through field glasses, under fire. After half an hour, retreat was sounded and we retired in good order. The regiment lost one man, Peleg Swift, Co. A, aged 45, the oldest man in the regiment killed, and had ten wounded. The left of the brigade rested on the Boydton Plank Road and the battle was not far from that other engagement of Oct. 27, 1864.
Slashing and Retreating
Among Gardner’s papers were found abstracts from the diary of Sergeant Bradley, not printed in the memorial book. He fails to mention that Captain Littlefield complimented him on the field for rallying men during the charge of March 31. But his story is perhaps the best of those preserved:
March 31, 1865. The sun came out about ten; it was most welcome. At eleven orders received to be ready to move in light marching order. The 1st Mass. and 5th Mich, passed over the work through the slashing into the heavy timber, past the picket lines. In about half an hour we were flanked on both sides, moved to the right a short distance, went forward to some slashing, ordered to retreat to the works, which we did; one killed and two wounded.
Another Phelps Sacrifice
All in all, the fighting on March 31, 1865, was a minor affair, except that one of those wounded that day was Pvt. Leroy Phelps. He must have suffered a serious wound. While it is not recorded, his brother Levant would have been nearby when Leroy was wounded since they were in the same company. Certainly, if he had not witnessed the actual event, he would have spent time with his brother before he was sent for further medical care.
The war did not stop for the regiment or Pvt. Levant Phelps. Both went on to fight in the final battles in Virginia. Petersburg fell on April 2, 1865. Then the final major battle with Lee’s army took place at Sailor’s Creek on April 6, 1865. There was one more small affair at High Bridge/Farmville on April 7, 1865. Then Lee surrendered the Army of Northern Virginia at Appomattox Court House on April 9, 1865. Pvt. Levant Phelps and the 1st Massachusetts Heavy Artillery attended the event. It was not the end of the war, but it was the end of fighting in Virginia.
Pvt. Leroy Phelps was quickly evacuated to the Union’s Satterlee Hospital in Philadelphia, Pa., where he died on April 11, 1865, two days after Lee’s surrender. Whether he knew of Lee’s surrender is unknown, but the news would have reached all of the North at the time. His mother’s undoubted joy at the end of the fighting in Virginia would soon be dashed when word reached her of her son’s death. His brother Levant may not have heard of the death for quite some time. Pvt. Leroy Phelps was interned in the military plot at Mount Moriah Cemetery in Philadelphia.
Homecoming and a Second Phelps Sacrifice
After Lee’s surrender, the 1st Massachusetts Heavy Artillery stayed in Virginia before marching to Washington, D.C. While there it manned several fortifications. It took part in the Grand Review on June 15, 1865. Eventually, the regiment mustered out in Washington on Aug. 16, 1865. Sent north to Boston, the regiment and Pvt. Levant Phelps were discharged at Gallop’s Island, Boston Harbor, on Aug. 25, 1865.

Levant Phelps attended the Grand Review of the Union Army. He may or may not have known of the latest Phelps sacrifice.
Levant Phelps’ homecoming must have been bittersweet. His widowed mother would still have been mourning his brother Leroy. But at the same time, Levant’s return must have overjoyed her. At least now she had a semblance of normal family life with her two surviving sons and daughter.
On June 3, 1867, Levant Phelps married Ella Lovinia Prince in Goshen, Mass. Finally, an event happened to bring some joy to the Phelps’ household. and his mother could now perhaps look forward to a grandchild.
But tragedy would once again strike the family. On 28 Nov 1869, Levant Phelps died of heart disease. He was only 25 years old. There is nothing to indicate a congenital condition, and it is entirely possible that the condition came about because of his hard war service. In any event, there were no children from the marriage. His mother Erryphila must have been a strong woman to survive – within 8 years she had lost a husband and two sons.
A Mother’s Enduring Scars
Erryphila Wheeler Phelps never remarried. She died on April 18, 1899, at Williamsburg, Hampshire County, Massachusetts. She apparently lived at the time with her daughter and her family. Her son Laselle and her daughter Ella Jane survived her. Both had children. Unfortunately, she had to survive one more tragedy when Laselle’s infant son died in 1896.
In one way or another, every family in the United States was left with the scars of war. The Phelps family was an ordinary family living, and dying, in extraordinary times. As such, they differed little from many of the families on both sides at the time.
Read more about the Phelps sacrifice here.
Abner Phelps was the author’s 2nd Cousin, 4 times removed, and his sons Leroy and Levant Phelps were his 3rd Cousins, 3 times removed.
***
Now available in paperback and as an ebook from the New England Historical Society! A collection of stories about the French people who came to America. Click here to order your copy today!









































