Home Massachusetts William Gordon, Annoying Minister, Wins Fight Over Ban on Clergy

William Gordon, Annoying Minister, Wins Fight Over Ban on Clergy

Tangles with John Adams over the Massachusetts Constitution

0 comment

In debating the first Massachusetts Constitution in 1780, John Lowell, lawyer of Newburyport and Roxbury, had a proposal. Ordained ministers should be barred from serving in the state’s Legislature. William Gordon, a minister not easily silenced, launched an attack on the idea.

John Adams, Samuel Adams, and James Bowdoin drafting the Massachusetts Constitution of 1780 in this painting by Albert Herter, which hangs in the Massachusetts Statehouse.

John Adams, Samuel Adams, and James Bowdoin drafting the Massachusetts Constitution of 1780 in this painting by Albert Herter, which hangs in the Massachusetts Statehouse.

Minister of the Third Parish Church of Roxbury, Gordon was an outspoken man. The attack on the clergy was not something he would quietly tolerate.

The ban on clergy went nowhere due to vigorous opposition from Gordon and other ministers.

William Gordon

That the outspoken Gordon would tackle the issue head on was typical of him. Gordon had came to America from England in 1770 because of his passion for the American cause. He had no official political office, but he still crossed many of the biggest figures in Massachusetts.

He opposed John Adams’ proposed limits on amendments to the first Massachusetts Constitution. Gordon suspected the founders of the Constitution wanted to prevent future generations from tampering with their work.

“He is an eternal talker, and somewhat vain, and not accurate nor judicious; fond of being thought a man of influence at headquarters; he is a good man, but wants a guide,” John Adams wrote of him.

Gordon lost his post as chaplain of the Provincial Congress because of his outspoken criticism of Massachusetts’ first, failed effort at a Constitution in 1778.

He upbraided John Hancock for his handling of accounts as treasurer of Harvard College. The resulting bad blood prompted Hancock to abandon his country estate in Roxbury (where Gordon held sway) for Boston.

And in his opposition to slavery, he would not be silenced. He was pleased by Massachusetts’ stand against slavery in its Constitution, but believed the nation needed to be united in outlawing it.

In an article critical of the Virginia Constitution, he wrote: “’All men are born free and independent’ . . . If these are our genuine sentiments, and we are not provoking the Deity by acting hypocritically to serve a turn, let us apply earnestly and heartily to the extirpation of slavery from among ourselves.”

Three Cheers for a Pratfall

Gordon was equally mercurial in his personal dealings. Students taking religious training from him noted he liberally beat them with a birch switch. One of his former pupils recalled that following close of school on one wintery day, Gordon slipped and fell on the icy steps as he went outside. His hat and wig went flying wildly in the air.

“We shouted in high glee, and gave three cheers,” his old student said.

In another incident related in Francis Samuel Drake’s The Town of Roxbury, Gordon visited the wealthiest man in his parish, Benjamin Pemberton. Pemberton often found Gordon’s demeanor unpleasant, and on this day the minister arrived at Pemberton’s home and hitched his horse to a newly painted fence.

Pemberton asked him to move it, and Gordon refused. He then directed his servant to move the horse, and Gordon again forbade it. Eventually, Gordon rode off in anger.

The bad blood persisted between the two men to the end. On his death bed, Pemberton refused a visit from Gordon and altered his will. Instead of leaving his estate to the church, he directed it to the service of the poor in Boston.

Back to England Goes William Gordon

Finally, in 1786, Gordon departed for England. He had spent several years reviewing the papers of George Washington, Henry Knox and Nathaneal Greene. He even sought, and received, dispensation from Congress to review Washington’s private papers.

Gordon said he intended to write an account of the Revolution to further educate British citizens about the war. The mercurial Gordon would seem the perfect candidate to write a no-holds-barred account of the rebellion, tinged with his blunt observations. It should have been a page turner.

Sadly, however, it seems he was thwarted. Gordon did find a British publisher, who released his: The history of the rise, progress, and establishment, of the independence of the United States of America. But far from being a fiery tell-all, the book was flat, stilted and not well-received.

No Best Seller

The reasons were revealed in the book Principles and acts of the Revolution in America written by researcher Hezekiah Niles. In it, he tells the story of his investigation into Gordon’s book.

“In 1790 . . . I was introduced to a relative of Doctor Gordon, of whom I inquired how the doctor had succeeded in his history. He smiled and said, ‘It was not Doctor Gordon’s history’.”

Niles reports that Gordon’s English publisher told him his book was too pro-America to sell to British audiences. The publisher also said it contained numerous libels against British officers. Even if Gordon’s stories of misdeeds by British soldiers were true, his publisher didn’t think he could defend the inevitable libel claims. He therefore could not afford to publish it. Disillusioned, Gordon asked what he should do. The publisher then helped him find a writer to “fix” the manuscript.

A dry recounting of the history of the war emerged. Gordon drew much of it from public documents. He did salt it liberally with quotations from letters that show some interesting details of the day-by-day events of the war. But the book lacked any of Gordon’s bomb-throwing style. The book sold poorly, and ultimately Gordon died a poor preacher in Ipswich, England, in 1807.

This story last updated in 2023. 

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Join our mailing list to receive the latest artciles from the New England Historical Society

Thanks for Signing Up!

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Join Now and Get The Latest Articles. 

It's Free!

You have Successfully Subscribed!