Home Arts and Leisure Maine’s Great Clam Chowder War of 1939

Maine’s Great Clam Chowder War of 1939

Chowder with tomato squares off against chowder without


A tomato-hating politician from Rockland set off the Maine clam chowder war of 1939 when he drafted a bill to criminalize clam chowder with tomato.

Guilty offenders would have to dig up a barrel of clams at high tide. As any clammer will tell you, that is not only cruel and unusual punishment, but impossible.

The hands-down winner

The hands-down winner of the clam chowder war.

State Rep. Cleveland Sleeper never got to file his bill, as the clam chowder war ended  without government interference.

A high-profile chowder contest settled the controversy. Such luminaries as Gov. Lewis O. Barrow and Ruth Wakefield, inventor of the chocolate-chip cookie, judged the contest.


Ruth Wakefield

The Clam Chowder War

Sleeper, a state representative since 1933, had facetiously prepared bills banning the tomato from clam chowder for several years. And then the Maine Hotel Association decided to end the clam chowder war at its mid-winter frolic in Portland.

Sleeper brought his chef. His rival, Philadelphia restaurateur Harry Tully, brought his.

Sleeper’s chef cooked up traditional Maine clam chowder, while Tully’s made tomato-based Manhattan Clam Chowder.


Lewis O. Barrow

“Each appealed to the palates of a distinguished gallery of chowder epicures,” reported the Associated Press in the Nashua Telegraph. “The epicures, headed by Maine’s Governor, Lewis O. Barrows, gravely sipped the rival concoctions.”

Sleeper tried the Manhattan chowder. “Ugh, this is a vegetable soup, not clam chowder,” he said.

The polluted loser

The polluted loser

“The tomato lends flavor to the clam,” retorted Tully.

Tully’s Manhattan Clam Chowder didn’t stand a chance. The judges voted unanimously for its New England rival.

“Maine Chowder Wins Over Tomato-Type” read the Lewiston Sun Journal headline. “Rep. Sleeper’s Campaign for “Unpolluted” Dish Is Successful.


Sleeper Triumphant

Then the story went on:  “Good old-fashioned New England clam chowder drew the nod of epicures here today in a battle de cuisine with its big-city sister, tomato-impregnated Manhattan clam chowder.”

Sleeper waxed triumphant. “If a clam could vote, I would be elected President,” he crowed.

Then a year later, Eleanor Early picked up the anti-tomato crusade in her 1940 book, A New England Sampler.There is a terrible pink mixture (with tomatoes in it and herbs) called Manhattan Clam Chowder, that is only a vegetable soup, and not to be confused with New England Clam Chowder, nor spoken of in the same breath,” she wrote. “Tomatoes and clams have no more affinity than ice cream and horseradish.”


Cleveland Sleeper then went on to somewhat greater political heights. He served in the Coast Guard Auxiliary during World War II and subsequently won election  to the Maine state Senate in 1945. He and his wife, Doris Bradlee Sleeper, had two daughters and three sons. A Rotarian, he ran a fuel-oil business for many years.

In April 1956, he wrote a letter to the editor of the Rotarian praising the magazine.

“Between The Rotarian, The Saturday Evening Post, Time magazine, and Rockland’s basketball team, I have very little time for television or other modern falderals,” he wrote.

Or, we presume, Manhattan Clam Chowder.

For Jacques Pepin’s New England Clam Chowder recipe, click here.

Images: “ManhattanClamChowder” by stu_spivack – Flickr. Licensed under CC BY-SA 2.0 via Wikimedia Commons. Ruth Wakefield By Source, Fair use, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?curid=40125741.

This story about the clam chowder war was updated in 2024. 


Christine McKenna March 4, 2015 - 10:15 pm

I like the red too. Shhh. Don’t tell.

Pat Strickland March 4, 2015 - 10:23 pm


Eric Foss March 4, 2015 - 10:48 pm

This Mainer like his chowder with NO MADERS !

Beth-Ann Scott March 4, 2015 - 10:48 pm

In Manhattan chowder, sure. New England, no way.

Bobo Leach March 4, 2015 - 11:09 pm

No tomatoes in my chowder!

Steve Magill March 4, 2015 - 11:21 pm

I slip in a can of diced tomatoes next time and let ya know

Steve Magill March 4, 2015 - 11:21 pm

I slip in a can of diced tomatoes next time and let ya know

Thelma Barnes March 5, 2015 - 1:43 am


Craig William Spencer March 5, 2015 - 7:27 am

They are all good as long as they have bacon in it.

Bonnie Warde March 5, 2015 - 11:48 am

No Tomatoes…

Brian Wentworth March 5, 2015 - 6:04 pm

They do not belong.

Ray Swartz March 12, 2015 - 7:43 am

A new chowder war is coming over whether bacon belongs in chowder. We pescetarians want a choice!

Karen Penrod March 13, 2015 - 1:15 pm

When I was much younger my family moved from New York to New England. I didn’t like Manhatten clam chowder when I lived in New York and certainly wouldn’t eat it by choice today! New England clam chowder is the only real chowder – no tomatoes!

John Alfred Poor Takes a Sleigh Ride, Steals a Railroad - New England Historical Society February 5, 2016 - 8:07 am

[…] Feb. 5, 1845, five days before the Maine Legislature granted the charter for his railroad, he set out from Portland in the most terrific snowstorm of […]

Quick Fact: In 1939, Maine Rep. Cleveland Sleeper introduced a bill to... - Quick Facts July 21, 2016 - 9:48 pm

[…] In 1939, Maine Rep. Cleveland Sleeper introduced a bill to make it illegal to add tomatoes to clam chowder.. Ref: http://www.newenglandhistoricalsociety.com/maines-great-clam-chowder-war-of-1939/ […]

#CoolFacts USA Edition Volume 2 - CoolLivin September 14, 2016 - 11:49 pm

[…] 7. In 1939, Maine Rep. Cleveland Sleeper introduced a bill to make it illegal to add tomatoes to clam chowder. – Source […]

Restaurant News: Time-saving trends for putting together a meal | My Edmonds News February 24, 2017 - 12:07 am

[…] as well as a culinary offense to introduce tomatoes into clam chowder. He was not successful, but here is a link if you’d like to read the whole story of the “war on […]

Lydia Sherman, the Derby Poisoner, Commits the Horror of the Century - New England Historical Society May 11, 2018 - 8:30 am

[…] suffered from some malady, so she put him out of his suffering with a large dose of arsenic in his clam chowder. Three excruciating days later, Hurlburt died, leaving Lydia $20,000 worth of real estate and […]

Tomato Facts - 19 Interesting Facts About Tomatoes | KickassFacts.com August 21, 2018 - 12:22 pm

[…] 10. In 1939, Maine Rep. Cleveland Sleeper introduced a bill to make it illegal to add tomatoes to clam chowder. – Source […]

New Englander December 11, 2018 - 12:20 am

Only communists put tomatoes in chowder.

50 American Food Facts – Fun State Trivia to Impress Your Friends | One World Media News June 4, 2019 - 1:07 pm

[…] take their soup so seriously that one lawmaker tried to criminalize adding tomatoes to their New England clam chowder back in […]

How the Quahog Became a Rhode Island Icon - New England Historical Society September 25, 2019 - 8:35 am

[…] Rhode Island embraced the hard-shelled bivalve. It made its way into important Rhode Island dishes like stuffies (stuffed clams), clams casino (a version of stuffies) and the controversial tomato-based clam chowder. […]

Fact of the Day - 30 Interesting Facts Of The Day | KickassFacts.com July 19, 2020 - 3:00 am

[…] In 1939, Maine Rep. Cleveland Sleeper introduced a bill to make it illegal to add tomatoes to clam chowder. – Source […]

Comments are closed.

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Join our mailing list to receive the latest artciles from the New England Historical Society

Thanks for Signing Up!

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Join Now and Get The Latest Articles. 

It's Free!

You have Successfully Subscribed!